• Home
  • News
    • All News
    • Movies
    • Comics
    • PlayStation 4
    • PlayStation 3
    • Xbox One
    • Xbox 360
    • PC
    • Indie
  • Reviews
    • All Reviews
    • Movies
    • PlayStation 4
    • PlayStation 3
    • Xbox One
    • Xbox 360
    • PC
    • Indie
  • Previews
  • Exclusives
    • All Exclusives
    • Columns
    • Opinions
    • Satire
    • Comics
    • Off-Topic
    • Guides
    • YouTube
  • Tech
By Caveshen on 7 May, 2013: published about 3 years ago
1 Comment

The Rumour Mill Is A Nasty Creation And You Should Not Listen To It

The Rumour Mill Is A Nasty Creation And You Should Not Listen To It

A few weeks ago a rumour dropped about the next-generation Xbox which claimed that it will be always-online, among other things.

Discussion over whether the world is ready for always-online or not escalated to the point that a Microsoft employee took to Twitter to voice his opinions regarding the matter, and was subsequently fired from the company.

  • Popular Articles
  • Recent Articles
    • You’ll Be Able To Play (Expensive) PS2 Games On Your PS4 Now | 2 months ago
    • Jessica Jones Disempowers Its Male Characters And The Effect Is Refreshing | 2 months ago
    • Hell Is 30 000 Deathclaws Tearing Through Boston And It’s Glorious | 2 months ago
    • Sony Santa Monica Is Teasing Something Truly Strange | 2 months ago
    • Goodbye | 2 weeks ago
    • EGMR Awards 2015: The Inevitable Wrap-Up | 1 month ago
    • EGMR Fun Awards 2015: Most MLG Moments | 1 month ago
    • EGMR Fun Awards 2015: Manliest Game | 1 month ago

    We of course maintained that if the rumours were true, Microsoft would be shooting themselves in the foot. However a new rumour has now surfaced which states almost the exact opposite, that the next-generation Xbox will function offline. Although in truth it does specify ‘single player games’ meaning it’s still entirely possible that some other games might need always-online to function.

    But the thing is, these are just more questions raised without answers, just yet. And sure, that’s great if you’re the type of person who enjoys just discussing things with others and speculating over the truth, but there are people making some serious decisions based off these rumours. And why, when they’re just rumours?

    The thing about rumours is, sometimes they can be true. And because of that, they are typically assumed to be inevitable rather than just somewhat possible.

    Developers, publishers, manufacturers, all know this.

    So let’s play two scenarios here.

    1. A developer wants to prototype a product it knows will not be met with great happiness, and so it leaks a rumour regarding the product. Entirely true, but presented in the form of something to be taken with a pinch of salt. Then it simply sits back and gauges responses. Are there people defending the rumour? Is there a decent number of supporters? Is everyone properly against it? Will it succeed, should the rumours prove true? And so on. Then, based on all of this, the developer can come out and either deny or confirm those rumours, and they have zero accountability. Plausible deniability, friends. Imagine if you will, then, that Microsoft wanted to field test the response to always-online, so they leaked the rumour, watched how the community reacted, and have now decided screw it, let’s plug that hole.

    2. A rival developer wants to pull off some espionage but doesn’t want to get caught, so it leaks a rumour about its rival which it knows will cause some trouble. The rumour could be entirely falsified but is believable enough that even the rival might consider it something to ponder, yet anyone with half a brain knows that it’s a bad idea and that the rival is playing with fire attempting to defend what is obviously not actually a thing. In this case, let’s think of Sony and their rivalry with Microsoft. Now what if, after the PS4 release, knowing that Microsoft was planning something, Sony released a rumour about always-online and Microsoft, instead of immediately denying the rumour, played it out to watch how the community reacted? Again, plausible deniability on both sides.

    Of course, all of this is just me allowing my imagination to run free and I have no proof of any of it, I am quite honestly just posing a few scenarios that I thought interesting.

    Nevertheless, regardless of what rumours currently exist, the truth will be revealed in just over two weeks from now, and surely enough a lot of people are going to have egg on their faces when their parts in the rumours prove to be unfounded. Oh, you defended the implementation of always-online and it’s not even a thing on the actual console? Well, you look like a genius, don’t you?

    I cannot stress how much we should be taking rumours, shoving them into some gaping abyss and pretending they don’t exist, if for nothing else than for the sake of our collective sanity. And of course, for the job safety of Microsoft’s employees.

    Look at all these pretty icons you can click:

    • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)
    • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on Google+ (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)

    Click Here, Read More. It's Easy.

    • 5 Nov, 2015
      Review: WWE 2K16 Understands Wrestling Fans But Not Game Design
    • 10 Dec, 2015
      EGMR Awards 2015: Best Story
    • 30 Nov, 2015
      Life, The Universe And Gaming: A Survivor’s Guide To Fallout 4 With A Partner
    • 22 Oct, 2015
      The EGMR Offensive #21: rAge And Other Things

    Name: Caveshen Rajman
    Location: Durban
    Position: Former Managing Editor

    Caveshen has published 2177 posts. Read all of Caveshen's posts.
    • Email Me
    • My RSS Feed
    • Follow Me On Twitter
    ZergNet
    • http://www.lomag.co.za/ NeoN

      What helped sell this rumor is the fact that Adam Orth was defending it with so much passion. If it was something to be dismissed, we wouldn’t have heard anything regarding the topic by Microsoft or it’s employees.

    FANS
    FOLLOWERS
    1262
    SUBS
    636
    Daily News. Sign Up Now.
    Offensive #23: Paragon Interrupt

    Hot Right Now

    • You’ll Be Able To Play (Expensive) PS2 Games On Your PS4 Now
      You’ll Be Able To Play (Expensive) PS2 Games On Your PS4 Now

    • Jessica Jones Disempowers Its Male Characters And The Effect Is Refreshing
      Jessica Jones Disempowers Its Male Characters And The Effect...

    • Hell Is 30 000 Deathclaws Tearing Through Boston And It’s Glorious
      Hell Is 30 000 Deathclaws Tearing Through Boston And It̵...

    • Sony Santa Monica Is Teasing Something Truly Strange
      Sony Santa Monica Is Teasing Something Truly Strange

    • Corsair Katar Review: A Splendid Dagger To The Heart
      Corsair Katar Review: A Splendid Dagger To The Heart

    • Life, The Universe And Gaming: A Survivor’s Guide To Fallout 4 With A Partner
      Life, The Universe And Gaming: A Survivor’s Guide To F...

    • Review: Fallout 4 Is Fantastic But Far From Flawless
      Review: Fallout 4 Is Fantastic But Far From Flawless

    Reviews

    • Review: Bulb Boy Is A Charming Exploration Of The Macabre Review: Bulb Boy Is A Charming Explorati...
      Marko | 50 Views | 85/100
    • Review: Star Wars Battlefront Is A Brief Ode To The Classics Review: Star Wars Battlefront Is A Brief...
      Bracken | 90 Views | 75/100
    • Review: Guitar Hero Live Evolves The Rhythm Game Genre And Will Halt Productivity Review: Guitar Hero Live Evolves The Rhy...
      Marko | 42 Views | 80/100
    • Review: Fallout 4 Is Fantastic But Far From Flawless Review: Fallout 4 Is Fantastic But Far F...
      Caveshen | 234 Views | 70/100
    • Review: Viscera Cleanup Detail – Unsatisfying Menial Labour Review: Viscera Cleanup Detail – U...
      A-G | 96 Views | 60/100

    Previews

    • Preview: It’s Attack On Wallet This Steam Holiday Sale Preview: It’s Attack On Wallet...
      Paul | Regret | 342 Views
    • Need For Speed Wants To Make You Do Sweet Drifts, Bro Need For Speed Wants To Make You Do ...
      Marko | Vin Diesel | 159 Views
    • The Siege Of Tom Clancy’s Rainbow Six The Siege Of Tom Clancy’s Rainbow Six
      Paul | Counter-Strike | 100 Views
    • Everything We Can Tell You To Expect In Halo 5: Guardians Everything We Can Tell You To Expect...
      Caveshen | Guilty Spark | 243 Views
    • Hands-On: Star Wars: Battlefront Has Potential, But Needs Serious Work Hands-On: Star Wars: Battlefront Has...
      Azhar | Spaaaaaaaace! | 598 Views

    Columns

    • Life, The Universe And Gaming: 2015: Muh Oppressions, And Other Things
      Life, The Universe And Gaming: 2015: Muh Oppressions, And Other Things

    • Abyssal Pixels: Role-Playing – The Absurd Versus The Faithful
      Abyssal Pixels: Role-Playing – The Absurd Versus The Faithful

    • Life, The Universe And Gaming: A Survivor’s Guide To Fallout 4 With A Partner
      Life, The Universe And Gaming: A Survivor’s Guide To Fallout 4 With A Partner

    Indie

    • Gone Home Officially Coming To Peasants
      Gone Home Officially Coming To Peasants

    • Review: Bulb Boy Is A Charming Exploration Of The Macabre
      Review: Bulb Boy Is A Charming Explorati...

    • RWBY: Grimm Eclipse Emerges From Shadows On To Steam Early Access
      RWBY: Grimm Eclipse Emerges From Shadows...

    • Latest Mighty No. 9 Trailer Shows Off Some Shiny New Gameplay
      Latest Mighty No. 9 Trailer Shows Off So...

    • Review: Viscera Cleanup Detail – Unsatisfying Menial Labour
      Review: Viscera Cleanup Detail – U...

      Interact

    • Submit a Tip
    • Suggest a Feature
    • The Team
    • Review System
    • Archives
    • Competitions

      support

    • Contact
    • Site or Article Error
    • Advertising
    • Competition T&C
      Creative Commons License

      stay connected

    • RSS Feed
    • Twitter
    • Twitter - Full Feed
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • Email Newsletter

      newsletter

      Enter your email address to receive our newsletter for news, articles and updates.
    Copyright © 2016 — #egmr. All Rights Reserved.
    A member of the Blotch Network with Clutchd Automotive.
    loading Cancel
    Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
    Email check failed, please try again
    Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.