• Home
  • News
    • All News
    • Movies
    • Comics
    • PlayStation 4
    • PlayStation 3
    • Xbox One
    • Xbox 360
    • PC
    • Indie
  • Reviews
    • All Reviews
    • Movies
    • PlayStation 4
    • PlayStation 3
    • Xbox One
    • Xbox 360
    • PC
    • Indie
  • Previews
  • Exclusives
    • All Exclusives
    • Columns
    • Opinions
    • Satire
    • Comics
    • Off-Topic
    • Guides
    • YouTube
  • Tech
By Adam on 7 Nov, 2012: published about 3 years ago
1 Comment

Experience Points: The Problem Is “Games Journalism”

Experience Points: The Problem Is “Games Journalism”

You’re probably coming into this column being fully aware of the PR versus ‘Games Journalism’ debate that has been rearing its ugly head in what many refer to as The Mountain Dew and Doritos Scandal, or Doritosgate if you prefer simplicity. What happened in Doritosgate, is symptomatic of issues that games journalism at its very foundation, which wasn’t that sturdy to begin with as is traditional journalism, itself is troubled. In the most traditional sense of ‘journalism’ one needs to understand that ‘objectivity’ was a keyword in the early days of journalism, when reporters hammered out copy in smoke covered hellholes known as press offices. In the early days, the concerns of writing articles were inundated with ethical practices such as double-checking your information sources, making sure that your ‘version’ of the truth was supported by fact and not fiction, and protecting your sources from possible threats. Journalists were meant to be gatekeepers to ‘truth’ as abstract as it sounds, and this tradition has heavily impacted what many now consider to be “games journalism”.

These traditional journalistic ideals have since proven to be a failure in the long run. Many major publications across the world have had to deal with the ethical onslaught of incorrect information being published and apologising for inaccurate stories that have caused character defamation, and lead to a long line of angry people ready to sue the asses off misguided journalists. However, the truth of the matter is that objectivity in journalism, and by extension, games journalism, is a fallacy. Objectivity in relation to journalism is equated with neutrality in the reporting of news, and writing news pieces which are primarily concerned with fairness, factuality and a disinterest in allowing outside forces influencing how a news story is printed, and represents the ‘truth’. What we can see now is that objectivity was one of the supposed ethics of journalism, along with fact checking and being unbiased in reporting the ‘truth’, which we can now look back and see is null, and void as a reality of real world news situations.

  • Popular Articles
  • Recent Articles
    • You’ll Be Able To Play (Expensive) PS2 Games On Your PS4 Now | 2 months ago
    • Jessica Jones Disempowers Its Male Characters And The Effect Is Refreshing | 2 months ago
    • Hell Is 30 000 Deathclaws Tearing Through Boston And It’s Glorious | 2 months ago
    • Sony Santa Monica Is Teasing Something Truly Strange | 2 months ago
    • Goodbye | 2 weeks ago
    • EGMR Awards 2015: The Inevitable Wrap-Up | 1 month ago
    • EGMR Fun Awards 2015: Most MLG Moments | 1 month ago
    • EGMR Fun Awards 2015: Manliest Game | 1 month ago

    No journalist can totally remove their opinion and bias from the copy they produce in a news article. This is an idealist’s dream and games journalism is no different. Just as modern journalism has become steeped in the computer and internet age, and journalists rarely venture far from their desk instead they rely on press releases as their main source of information, and rehash them into articles. One needs to accept that games journalism has experienced the same conditions, which have made it thrive as an overall development online, which means that it is rarely plausible to expect any piece of games journalism to be impartial and objective.

    By extension, I feel that labelling ‘Games Journalism’ as a type of journalism is problematic and riddled with issues. Most game journalists, and of course this is generalising here, are not in any way journalists or express to be so. Even the traditional print and television journalists who proclaim themselves to be hard news journalists are nothing more than vacuous PR entities that punt political agendas, and take influence from corporate sponsors. Just as Edward R. Murrow, the preeminent American TV journalist during the 1950s, proclaimed television journalism to be a dead horse which caved into corporate advertising and pandered to consumerism, so too is modern journalism and games journalism. Both modern journalism and games journalism are slowly turning into glorified PR machines. Murrow in a 1958 speech addressed the state of network television and prime time news, and said:

    Our history will be what we make it. And if there are any historians about fifty or a hundred years from now, and there should be preserved the kinescopes for one week of all three networks, they will there find recorded in black and white, or color, evidence of decadence, escapism and insulation from the realities of the world in which we live. I invite your attention to the television schedules of all networks between the hours of 8 and 11 p.m., Eastern Time. Here you will find only fleeting and spasmodic reference to the fact that this nation is in mortal danger. There are, it is true, occasional informative programs presented in that intellectual ghetto on Sunday afternoons. But during the daily peak viewing periods, television in the main insulates us from the realities of the world in which we live. If this state of affairs continues, we may alter an advertising slogan to read: LOOK NOW, PAY LATER.

    Murrow’s speech may have happened during the rise of network news television in America, but it resonates with so many forms of media and press coverage. The relationship between corporations and news entities is not old news. It is still relevant today, as demonstrated in what happened during Doritosgate. Doritosgate is just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to games journalism.

    The point is that games journalists are writers and critics who happen to have a passion that centres on gaming and is duly expressed in their articles and the publications they write for. Most of the articles you see on gaming websites aren’t fact checked or based on traditional news sources, as dictated by the standards and ethics of journalism. Gaming websites don’t have in-the-field reporters scouting out sources and getting to the ‘truth’. Nearly all of what could be called field reporting only happens in the instances of expos and press events.

    I won’t deny that writers cannot be ‘press, but labelling them as journalists further complicates matters, as mentioned above. To be honest, I find the term journalist to be of its own a problematic term and for gaming to take it on as a demarcation of the people writing about issues involving gaming, it is confounding. The individuals who write about games and news surrounding them are made of opinions and subjective viewpoints that counter one another from time to time. They are also subject to the allure of PR offerings from publishers which in some cases may reflect influence in review scores of some gaming websites. Yet this is not true for all gaming websites, and making an issue of when gaming websites take advantage of PR perks in lowering the cost of expenses, for example, comes across as an unflinchingly stupid act. The hypocrisy in the industry is most apparent when it comes to talking about issues such as this.

    As such, to label writing about games as “games journalism’ is a failure to understand that journalism as a concept is fallible and a ethical nightmare of hypocrisy. I am not arguing that writers should not be impartial and fair in the assessment of games, and in the articles they write up. However, we shouldn’t be quick to judge said writers in terms of traditional journalistic expectations which apply to an industry inadequately. Games journalism is a confounding concept, and games journalists are only human.

    Look at all these pretty icons you can click:

    • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)
    • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on Google+ (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)

    Click Here, Read More. It's Easy.

    • 25 Nov, 2015
      Toast On Jam: Fallout 4 And Backwards Compatibility – Gaming’s Unhealthy Obses…
    • 11 Nov, 2015
      Toast On Jam: What The Hell Was EA Thinking With Need For Speed?
    • 11 Nov, 2015
      Why I’m Proud Of This Industry After Seven Years Of Fighting With It
    • 28 Oct, 2015
      Toast On Jam: Female Hoodlums And Street Racing – How Accurate Is AC Syndicate?

    Name: Adam Meikle
    Location: Durban
    Position: Ex-Editor, Indie

    Adam has published 431 posts. Read all of Adam's posts.
    • Email Me
    • My RSS Feed
    • Follow Me On Twitter
    ZergNet
    • http://www.facebook.com/brendon.bosch Brendon Bosch

      Dude i so wanna read this article but it`s late. Do me a solid and comment on this comment then i will read it totally tomorrow night cause i read a bit and it caught my attention. Favour for a friend please

    FANS
    FOLLOWERS
    1262
    SUBS
    636
    Daily News. Sign Up Now.
    Offensive #23: Paragon Interrupt

    Hot Right Now

    • You’ll Be Able To Play (Expensive) PS2 Games On Your PS4 Now
      You’ll Be Able To Play (Expensive) PS2 Games On Your PS4 Now

    • Jessica Jones Disempowers Its Male Characters And The Effect Is Refreshing
      Jessica Jones Disempowers Its Male Characters And The Effect...

    • Hell Is 30 000 Deathclaws Tearing Through Boston And It’s Glorious
      Hell Is 30 000 Deathclaws Tearing Through Boston And It̵...

    • Sony Santa Monica Is Teasing Something Truly Strange
      Sony Santa Monica Is Teasing Something Truly Strange

    • Corsair Katar Review: A Splendid Dagger To The Heart
      Corsair Katar Review: A Splendid Dagger To The Heart

    • Life, The Universe And Gaming: A Survivor’s Guide To Fallout 4 With A Partner
      Life, The Universe And Gaming: A Survivor’s Guide To F...

    • Review: Fallout 4 Is Fantastic But Far From Flawless
      Review: Fallout 4 Is Fantastic But Far From Flawless

    Reviews

    • Review: Bulb Boy Is A Charming Exploration Of The Macabre Review: Bulb Boy Is A Charming Explorati...
      Marko | 49 Views | 85/100
    • Review: Star Wars Battlefront Is A Brief Ode To The Classics Review: Star Wars Battlefront Is A Brief...
      Bracken | 90 Views | 75/100
    • Review: Guitar Hero Live Evolves The Rhythm Game Genre And Will Halt Productivity Review: Guitar Hero Live Evolves The Rhy...
      Marko | 42 Views | 80/100
    • Review: Fallout 4 Is Fantastic But Far From Flawless Review: Fallout 4 Is Fantastic But Far F...
      Caveshen | 232 Views | 70/100
    • Review: Viscera Cleanup Detail – Unsatisfying Menial Labour Review: Viscera Cleanup Detail – U...
      A-G | 94 Views | 60/100

    Previews

    • Preview: It’s Attack On Wallet This Steam Holiday Sale Preview: It’s Attack On Wallet...
      Paul | Regret | 342 Views
    • Need For Speed Wants To Make You Do Sweet Drifts, Bro Need For Speed Wants To Make You Do ...
      Marko | Vin Diesel | 158 Views
    • The Siege Of Tom Clancy’s Rainbow Six The Siege Of Tom Clancy’s Rainbow Six
      Paul | Counter-Strike | 100 Views
    • Everything We Can Tell You To Expect In Halo 5: Guardians Everything We Can Tell You To Expect...
      Caveshen | Guilty Spark | 242 Views
    • Hands-On: Star Wars: Battlefront Has Potential, But Needs Serious Work Hands-On: Star Wars: Battlefront Has...
      Azhar | Spaaaaaaaace! | 598 Views

    Columns

    • Life, The Universe And Gaming: 2015: Muh Oppressions, And Other Things
      Life, The Universe And Gaming: 2015: Muh Oppressions, And Other Things

    • Abyssal Pixels: Role-Playing – The Absurd Versus The Faithful
      Abyssal Pixels: Role-Playing – The Absurd Versus The Faithful

    • Life, The Universe And Gaming: A Survivor’s Guide To Fallout 4 With A Partner
      Life, The Universe And Gaming: A Survivor’s Guide To Fallout 4 With A Partner

    Indie

    • Gone Home Officially Coming To Peasants
      Gone Home Officially Coming To Peasants

    • Review: Bulb Boy Is A Charming Exploration Of The Macabre
      Review: Bulb Boy Is A Charming Explorati...

    • RWBY: Grimm Eclipse Emerges From Shadows On To Steam Early Access
      RWBY: Grimm Eclipse Emerges From Shadows...

    • Latest Mighty No. 9 Trailer Shows Off Some Shiny New Gameplay
      Latest Mighty No. 9 Trailer Shows Off So...

    • Review: Viscera Cleanup Detail – Unsatisfying Menial Labour
      Review: Viscera Cleanup Detail – U...

      Interact

    • Submit a Tip
    • Suggest a Feature
    • The Team
    • Review System
    • Archives
    • Competitions

      support

    • Contact
    • Site or Article Error
    • Advertising
    • Competition T&C
      Creative Commons License

      stay connected

    • RSS Feed
    • Twitter
    • Twitter - Full Feed
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • Email Newsletter

      newsletter

      Enter your email address to receive our newsletter for news, articles and updates.
    Copyright © 2016 — #egmr. All Rights Reserved.
    A member of the Blotch Network with Clutchd Automotive.
    loading Cancel
    Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
    Email check failed, please try again
    Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.